|
|
|
Sweet Melissa (above) and Colson (right).
|
A few Saturdays ago, we decided to stop in and try out Sweet
Melissa, the new pastry shop on 7th
avenue between 1st and 2nd. We ogled a tempting assortment of goodies in the display counter as we entered, and our mouths began watering. A harried hostess escorted us to a table in the rear courtyard, and said a server would be
right with us.
Our menus said "ask our servers about our daily
selections." We were very eager to ask,
but it was a full ten minutes before we got the chance. Things did not bode
well when the virtually catatonic server finally arrived, and suggested that we head back to the
front counter to peruse the selections rather than rely on her to recite them.
Luckily, I had already decided on a scone, and Pipistrelle on a slice of almond
encrusted bread pudding. Unluckily, they were already sold out of scones, so I decided to skip the pastry
and just order some vanilla tea (it was quite good). Pipistrelle ordered the
almond bread pudding, but sometime between her utterance and the delivery of the goods, that got translated that into "banana
chocolate" bread pudding (they sound so similar). We were too frustrated
at this point to send the dish back, so she shrugged and dug in. I can't speak for
Pipistrelle, but I thought the pudding was soggy, dense, and bland.1
Based on our first visit, I couldn’t recommend Sweet Melissa
at all.
The next day, we stumbled on Colson (9th and 6th) on our way to brunch, and decided to give it
a try. Although it was much smaller than Sweet Melissa, the selection was suprisingly diverse, and the quality of our food was outstanding. The service wasn’t
spectacular, but in comparison to Sweet Melissa it was exemplary, especially
given the small space and busy counter. We both had quiche, and it is without a
doubt the best quiche I’ve had in New York.
When I make quiche, the crust is crispy, the
contents are savory, but the filling is more akin to a frittata than custard. I
find most quiches at restaurants around here are similar – very flavorful, but
certainly not delicate. By contrast, the Colson quiche filling has the consistency of panna
cotta or crème brulee, and it's seated in a firm, flaky crust – I’ve never had anything like it. Their café au lait was pretty darned good too.
Of course, I wouldn’t want to pass judgment based on just one visit. So I decided to
give both establishments the croissant test. In my opinion, the standard by
which one should judge any patisserie is the quality of their croissant. I
admit that this standard is flawed given that what constitutes the
"perfect" croissant is ultimately a matter of taste, but the
variables that matter for me are: flakiness, butteriness, and
"weight." A doughy, leaden croissant with not a hint of butter flavor
is a zero, while a light, ultra-flaky butter bomb is Nirvana. By this measure,
Colson is the clear winner. The Sweet Melissa croissant is decent (3 out of 5), but it can’t
compete with Colson’s (4.5 out of 5). The
difference is service was evident on my subsequent visit as well. The counter
at Sweet Melissa was in complete disarray, while the service at Colson was
delayed but adequate.
In the interest of fairness, I did witness a huge service faux pas at Colson
on my most recent visit. A fairly long line had formed at the counter, but only
one person was attending to the needs of the patrons. This situation developed
while another employee morosely counted out the contents of the tip jar in full
view of the people who were waiting to be served (ten minutes!). I saw one
woman leave in frustration.
Here’s my tip – if your shift is over, at least have the sense to count out your tips in the back.
Still, I chalk that incident up as an outlier and declare Colson the clear winner for now. I'm fully prepared for the blood feud that I'm courting with the Sweet Melissa devotees, but deep in your heart you all know the truth.
1 Of course, nothing can compare to the chocolate bread pudding at Blue Ribbon.
Recent Comments